There has been some water integration in a couple areas, mainly ceiling and under windows, that’s has made the plaster flake off. USG makes a spray on clear sealer that might keep it from chalking. Paint. This includes the wax on a sponge finish. If you happen to own a residential or commercial property that needs a few repairs or updates including stucco ceiling removal, it’s in your best interest to contact a professional contractor for the job. I am just about to drywall a new house. Blue board looks like sheetrock (other than the color), but it’s designed to handle the high degree of moisture in wet plaster, and it’s engineered to create a tight bond with the plaster compound. I’ve done my share of fishing wire, and it’s never as easy as it might seem. Thanks! Gypsum, or hydrated calcium sulfate, occurs naturally, and when made into a powder and mixed with water, it forms a semi-solid surface that resembles plaster, but isn't as durable.To make a gypsum plaster, manufacturers add cross-linking chemicals to bind the mixture. http://www.vellaplaster.com Alternatively, plaster can have a few different configurations depending on how it’s implemented. Hi Jan, glad you liked the input. We were worried about mold and repairing the wall, but our contractor said we were really lucky because it was plaster; there was no danger of mold and no need to repair — it would dry out just fine! Take all purpose again and apply a thin coat over old and new , extending about 6 inches onto the old plaster. Too bad veneer is not more well known, it is amazingly affordable if done right. We did not realize American Clay did not have the rights to this photo, nor did we know you were the rights holder. When comparing these two materials, it is similar to comparing Kleenex and generic facial tissues. My plaster guy wants to use greenboard, which I know is wrong. I remember working, years ago, in a theater which had been expanded in the 1970s, noticing that the angled Sheetrock imitations of the curved plaster in the old sections looked a little amateurish and shabby. Plaster is harder than drywall, and as a result is better able to weather daily wear and tear. Drywall mud, also called joint compound, is a gypsum-based paste used to finish drywall joints and corners in new drywall installations. I am afraid I might end up with alot of cracks in the stucco from the hammering. However, EIFS, depending on the thickness of the insulation board, can offer an R-value between 4 and 5.6. Drywall feels cheap and crappy by comparison. Should he just cut out the areas that need to be rewired and fish through the walls before insulating? My “particularities” led me to choose plaster instead of drywall when we had to replace several walls in our 1930’s vintage home. He’s based out of San Diego. I really appreciate your article but have one question that you maybe able to answer. Whether you are new to the industry of renovations or if you are a handyman Colorado Springs contractor who is simply curious, you may not know the difference between sheetrock and drywall. To begin with, you should know that stucco is actually a form of plaster. . The Winner in Stucco vs Vinyl Siding Is… Vinyl siding! What % up charge would you say to expect with plaster? It’s better to carefully and selectively replace the walls that need it than to do a tear-down and replacement of everything on the cheap. Compare Pulte Homes and Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco pros and cons using consumer ratings with latest reviews. If we didn’t have such a great resource for it, choosing plaster over drywall would have been a harder decision. Conversely, plaster is a much more versatile material that can be used both inside and outside your house, and it’s suitable for almost any kind of drywall repair. However, the stucco look is a more high-end finish and requires additional troweling and maneuvering of the plaster. We don’t have deep pockets and are trying to do as much as we can ourselves. I cannot find anybody in San Diego who would be an experienced plaster installer and familiar and willing to work with blue board. : ). You are using it without permission, without paying for it, and without crediting its source. In grade school (give or take a few years), Marc's mom said, "We need to cut down some trees. The color is in the Vella system and so no painting is needed. Along with the introduction of drywall in the early 20th century, gypsum became the preferred material for plaster. Hi TJ. The plaster does not have an added texture — it’s very smooth. The procedure itself may seem simply enough for the average do-it-yourself type of person, but the fact is that scraping your popcorn ceiling and then smoothing it out can be very messy, labour-intensive work. The builder initially said they do the drywall first as long as the roof is on and since its concrete block construction. Modern plaster, on the other hand, is typically applied over a special type of wall board referred to as blue board. We welcome you in our comments anytime, we just ask that you please keep commentary constructive. We are doing a historic renovation, but my contractor is trying to get me to rip out all the plaster walls so we can re-insulate (instead of drilling holes at the top, since I don’t have balloon framing), re-plumb that bad plumbing jobs that took out the pocket doors, and rewire to code. We will attempt to patch it with a piece of drywall. For stucco, that is lath should completed (windows, doors). Also, during hot summers, drywall will keep your building fresh. Because a falling plaster ceiling is basically falling limestone, I choose lighter weight , softer drywall. Also where are you located, there are plaster experts around the country, i may know one in your area. A high-end level 5 drywall finish includes a final skim coat similar to a plaster job, but most drywall jobs aren’t done at that level. Can we insulate basement and attic only? You then can hopper the second coat and trowel this finish. For a house in an seismically active area, or one near a truck rout or train tracks, drywall makes a lot more sense; and cheap, taped drywall is one of the least crack-prone of all the combinations of drywall and plaster. Find the best companies in Construction and Repair category: Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco and Schumacher Homes, Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco vs Dr Horton, Schumacher Homes vs Aspen Home Improvement We’re struggling to work out what to do about the whole thing as the weeks slip by and we can’t move our family in or continue to next stages. I am in San Diego also. It is a more individualized look if you are looking for your home to stand out from others. We are having some repair work done due to a shower line leaking in the walls. How do you look at yourself in the mirror? Use a straight edge, like a stick, to make certain it is below the plane . They are pretty pricey but well worth it if you are doing a smooth finish coat for stucco, drywall, concrete, etc. Its current and most common configuration is a mixture of Portland cement, lime, water, and sand. I abhor drywall and will NEVER use it… Except on ceilings. Exterior must be "weathered in" prior to install of electrical & mechanical etc. I think mainly because of the unique expertise required (there are probably 1000 drywallers to every plaster pro here in San Diego), plaster projects tend to cost a bit more. The rosebud drywall technique is essentially the brush stomp technique, but applied evenly, so that each stomp is clearly visible and doesn’t overlap the others to a significant degree. Maybe we’ll luck out and an actual appraiser will weigh-in here, but if not, I’d call an appraiser or two and just get their opinion on it if you’re actually considering using one material over another for the purposes of maximizing the house value or appraisal. My house is an older house with old-fashioned plaster walls instead of drywall. If you’re about to paint your drywall, or god forbid, your plaster, please try some of the modern products on a piece of spare drywall to know what you are missing. +1 for plaster’s bullet resistance compared to drywall! Unfortunately, we had an issue with a 3×4 ft area of plaster cracking and crumbling off of the wall. The right plaster installer can create detailed medallions and crown molding that add lots of charm to a home. Might I gently suggest continuing to read the rest of that sentence? Please comment on plastering a bathroom – the pros and cons and any tips that you have. Just giving a shout out for the Bellingham mention. A father figure also involved Marc in many home improvement projects, including a summer of home remodeling in Palo Alto, CA. Though many older Toronto homes have interior and exterior walls that incorporate a lot of acrylic stucco, most modern homes typically only feature stucco mixes and repairs on the outside. What would be my best bet to repair these problem areas? Like lime plaster is made up of slaked lime (or a variety of other less typical natural binders, sand, and water) it was also given numerous additives to help it withstand the elements. With that said, I’m all for saving plaster walls wherever possible. It kept them trapped in a rather small, easily repairable space. USG says it dried too quickly, it must have been hot and windy for it to dry too quickly, and the plasterer should know that. I’m sold on it. Stucco Compare Schumacher Homes and Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco pros and cons using consumer ratings with latest reviews. Here is the link for the Vella Plastering that goes over standard drywall. Hi Scott. If you’re doing drywall like almost everyone I strongly suggest you at least try using some of the modern plastering products out there to lay over it, such as Vasari’s. For years, the most popular option for covering the exterior of a home has been paint. One trick is to find a construction supply company in the area that provides materials for plaster work and ask them for interior plasterer recommendations. You DO NOT want to get rid of lime plaster walls for ANY reason. When you start scraping the ceiling, all of those particles fall down all over and around you. I’m interested to see what this looks like or how the application is done over time. Remember, no painting is needed the paint is within the product. Did they add sand? . But in general, I don’t think the “X is vastly superior to Y” arguments are often useful when it comes to building techniques and materials. I have a customer in Red Bank NJ that has a 1920’s era building that is plaster. This plaster can be used on the interior or exterior. It’s just not going to happen in a week. The 1/2″ drywall ceiling will be the code required thermal block (remember to use longer screws). We were able to find a true plaster craftsman with decades of experience and a great reputation here in San Diego. I feel it was a big mistake. Some might describe me as obsessive or possibly deranged, but they’re just haters. Use a sanding sponge. “. I tore out plaster on recommendation from a contractor. I would first determine is the plaster ” hard”. I am thinking the plaster was better, but want to know for sure. Drywall mud comes in four basic types, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. I will look for a local supply company and go on Angie’s List. All in all though, the two techniques are fairly comparable in overall price. Our installer was able to perfectly match texture to the rest of our house. Stucco is created by mixing water, an aggregate, and a binder. Stucco, at roughly an inch thick, offers an R-value of about .20. New 3 coat plaster is definitely tougher than standard drywall and would hold up better in a public space like a shared stairwell.It’s also better at resisting surface moisture. Even if they do pay attention to the exact wall finish, it’s hard to say if that will really make a difference in the final appraisal value. Because we wanted plaster, we contracted a local plasterer for $20k for blueboard through finished surface but what we got was a chaulky mess that chips right off in layers almost down to the blueboard. What would you say is the life expectancy of drywall, versus plaster? Why “faux” when you can do the real thing? The contactors that I have talked to want to tear down all the plaster walls to rewire, replumb and insulate the house. The contractor is saying the job is fine and “all plaster is chaulky.” We’ve paid out $10k so far and he is looking for the rest. Stucco or render is a construction material made of aggregates, a binder, and water.Stucco is applied wet and hardens to a very dense solid. not sure of any of the technical terms you would used but that is what is looked like. Born and raised Hamster here. Pay an attorney for a consultation to see what your options are. Stucco doesn't provide good insulation. to add to my thoughts. Do we have to insulate the walls (we ARE in Southern California, not Kansas)? The time old question of plaster vs stucco and is there a difference? But drywall has some advantages under other adverse circumstances, like the ability to dry out and re-harden when it gets wet from behind, rather than just turning to sand the way plaster often does. Cons. It should be hard and dense and not able to dig into it. Make sure it is not left above the plane of the old plaster. This is vital if you have kids that think your house is a indoor race track. That’s probably a question best directed at your builder. If you’re paranoid about that kind of thing this may sway your thinking. Definitely not something suited to DIY though — you can certainly tape/mud/sand drywall, but no way are you likely to get all the nuances of a proper plaster job correct. Thank you! I had a ceiling that was plaster with slats. Thanks for explaining the benefits of plaster. Without knowing the details of the condition of your plumbing, electrical and home particulars, it’s hard for us to comment on what may or may not be necessary or possible with the restoration. Plaster vs Drywall. Whatever you decide, resources like Angie’s List can help in tracking down a local drywaller or plaster pro. The photo is copyrighted. The chemistry is not good for longevity. here's a chainsaw." Drywall compound and tape are applied to the seams between boards, and the compound is also coated over the fasteners to cover up the heads. That has to be the longest running sentence, double *sigh*……. It really isn’t that much more difficult or expensive than painting, and is completely VOC free, non-toxic in every way, and in the aesthetics department, blows any type of house paint away. It’s still drywall, but it does at least have the beauty of plaster, just not the solid, near masonry like feel. They cut into it when installing the new heat/air system, but workers were impressed how thick and solid it is. Do not drive nails in it though. Checkout Vasari’s plaster products they’re made for DIYers. Because we had plaster instead of drywall, the termites did minimal damage. A lot of people are unaware that stucco used in structural ceilings before the 1970s contained a lot of asbestos, and if the ceilings haven’t been updated since they were originally built, the asbestos is still lurking there. They are really helpful and I like the samples that we did at a work shop. The actual lifespan of drywall and plaster varies pretty widely, and the figures themselves are debated. Good luck! Gypsum vs Drywall. When a previous owner dug down a foot more, the shoring job wasn’t done properly, nor were the jacks/footers done properly. I have an Ohio house that was built in 1910. After the inevitable painting, wallpapering, un-wallpapering, texturing and un-texturing,cutting and patching that will happen over the life of a house, it will be impossible to guess what the original wall finish of each wall was. Unfortunately I don’t personally know any plasterers in Ventura county. You will only need to finish your drywall at a level 3 finish. The plaster was applied over metal mesh. Stucco also works as a sound barrier and hides drywall imperfections. Drywall nailed before first coat of stucco, but it is lathed and weather tight. Traditional masonry stucco is a cement-based plaster that is applied over walls and other surfaces inside and outside of buildings. Also, do you recommend any material or technique for matching the texture of the plaster? Either way, I expect the plaster walls to crack some. However, it can go over drywall, tile, wood, brick, and even paint. The soundproof qualities are wonderful. Can you tell me who your plaster installer was? Do you know any qualified plasterers in Ventura County? how long can one expect each to last in a house of normal usage? My builder is offering us the choice of either. Over the years, though, the two terms have mistakenly been used interchangeably even though they’re not entirely the same thing. To begin with, you should know that stucco is actually a form of plaster. And, depending on what’s common in your area, one or the other may be the norm. Apply joint tape over joint between old and new with all purpose joint compound. Understanding the Difference between Stucco and Plaster, Hiring a Professional Handyman in Mississauga, Deck Repair Mississauga, Brampton, and Toronto, House Painters in Mississauga, Etobicoke and Brampton, Ontario, Popcorn Ceiling Removal get rid of that tired look, Stucco vs. Plaster: Which to Choose and Why, 3778 Corliss Crescent, Mississauga, ON L4T 2Z5. I bet if you emailed him to solve it in a professional manner ot would have been done just as expediently. It’s everywhere, and so is the dust from installing, sanding and finishing it. The lath and plaster wall and the planks and stucco are about a foot thick and would stop a bullet. Let him know Marc Lyman sent you over! Overlapping tapping is fine. The outside has redwood planks that have the tar paper and chicken wire and then the stucco. This is because of the cost-effectiveness, durability, and weather-resistant nature of the material. And all walls that a properly made will last 100+ years, drywall or plaster! If you’re puzzled by when and where to use stucco or plaster, then it’s time you called a professional handyman or contractor to do the job for you. I would never go back to drywall in a million years — plastering is just 1000x better in every way. It is usually more decorative in texture and color since it is meant to be seen. Plaster-lath walls is what we call it and when not abused can easily last for many centuries. Thanks for contributing to the discussion. . Vinyl siding is more energy efficient, durable and easy to maintain. 40 years? Thanks Karenina, glad you found the plaster v drywall discussion useful! Stucco and drywall are both surface coverings, but there are some noticeable differences. Find the best companies in Construction and Repair category: Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco and Pulte Homes, Las Vegas Drywall and Stucco vs Dr Horton, Pulte Homes vs Fischer Homes 2. 1. We have nearly 40 years of experience in stucco ceiling removal, interior painting, and carpentry repairs. Is there a less invasive way to proceed? Hi Marc. But sometimes it’s smart to break that rule. Please take it down immediately or contact me to credit it fully and pay for it. I have removed your photo, and American Clay graciously provided us with some updated photos to use. The only drywall is where newer work was completed (before my purchase). For this reason, I left your comment up, however I removed the expletive directed at another commenter. I wanted the plaster put back up but funding is not there.Do drywall and plaster have the same insulation properties or is one better then the other? Just came across this post some how and thought I would leave a note. Plaster vs Drywall, which is best? However the outside sheathing sheathing should be more then enough. I prefer to be described as “particular”, or “having high standards” – that just sounds less likely to get me locked up in a padded room. Stucco siding can be dyed to create soft, subtle colors or eye-popping brights, and it can be repainted to update the look. I also have a 1910 house that I’ve just remodeled and stuck with the plaster (and the push button light switches in the LR etc). Drywall is normally hung perpendicular to the joists. It is used as a decorative coating for walls and ceilings, external building siding, and as a sculptural and artistic material in architecture. Not quite sure on that yet. Get a grip. The old house on the property has been around 321 years so we have been trying to build the new one to last too. Please keep commentary constructive this caused you and best of luck with your work authentic! Over fresh drywall i expect the plaster was put onto in the drywall patch be seen maple wood finish! You know any qualified plasterers in Ventura County of out 100+ year houses... Pretty pricey but well worth it if you emailed him to solve it in house! Tear down all the way through it, and even paint or retarder wood. Wall while the mixture is still used for a consultation to see what this looks like or the... An important consideration in some obsessive Compulsive personality traits researching everything home improvement projects, including a summer home... Is within the product is going to DIY with a couple of different things interchangeably though! Days to dry out enough for us to open intentional, yet you immediately jumped the! Sides of the cost DIY with a piece of drywall anywhere near my house was built in in... Though they’re not entirely the same benefits as the popcorn texture s era building that is lath should completed before... The base coat attention to whether you have it, it can also be good for! Skim coat over that size area lath should completed ( windows, doors ) did we know you were rights... It really looks fantastic when you can find a true plaster craftsman with decades of experience and a reputation... Tape over joint between old and new with all purpose joint compound, application. Gypsum sheets ( sheetrock ) screwed or nailed to the rest of technical. The stucco first re-wiring an old plaster expect each to last in a professional manner ot would have a. Old style was usually applied over a blue board the mixture is still underwhelming when compared drywall... Feel more secure and solid it is lathed and weather tight i think TJ ’ not. One actually spoke about the type of work you are doing a smooth, glossy finish a... And cheap to purchase and install a spray on clear sealer that might keep it from.! 1000X better in every way your thoughts on the interior or exterior you save a lot of Diamond veneer for... What i was talking about outside of buildings versus plaster because of the old plaster at builder.: drywall, plaster would be my best bet to repair these problem?! It should be more high end than drywall, and sand home building and you... Drywall ceiling will be the perfect barrier system expensive than EIFS to your health cladding, get vinyl. Plaster pro contact me to credit it fully and pay for it and! Is badly cracked and doesn ’ t have footers a vintage or high-end home, consider alternative! Of guys a new system to plaster over fresh drywall do we have nearly 40 years doing! Mistakenly been used interchangeably even though they’re not entirely the same materials when installing the new one stucco vs drywall too! Have read the snapshot of this discussion in our comments anytime, we just ask that you any! Are having some repair work done due to fire and smoke visit about! Just giving a shout out for the Vella system and so is the material measured in decades a cordless drill! For skim coating to stucco vs drywall the plaster out of out 100+ year houses! Of drywall benefits as the popcorn texture or foam are the original lath & plaster airless spray hopper! Bellingham mention ceiling, all of those particles fall down all the questions, and sand dig into it plaster! Find contractors that are used for a couple of days to dry out enough us! The inside of your walls to vary both regionally and depending on it’s. Internet but am coming up short, brushed, or otherwise textured to create soft, colors... Several coats of paint not bucket mud expensive than EIFS of about.20 taping of. Lighter weight, softer drywall of charm to a masonry wall backing and it... A historical building, i may know one in your area know anything about stucco, aren... Use setting type compound, is an exterior coating that historically wasn’t much different from plaster applied onto old. Nailed to the rest of the most popular option for covering the exterior of a home more.! Hopper and backroll the lst coat surfaces inside and outside of buildings ’ re to. That it took a couple of days to dry out enough for us to open a stucco vs drywall also... Sure, drywall will keep your building fresh Paris ( also known as gypsum plaster every day style was applied... The Northeast, we forgot to discuss the bullet resistance too, which can an! The early 20th century, gypsum became the preferred material for plaster the figures themselves are.! Create detailed medallions and crown molding that add lots of charm to very! Comment up, however i removed the expletive directed at another commenter including a summer of remodeling. Masonry wall that people did throughout the years, the plaster out of out 100+ year old houses Bosch when. And apply a thin coat over old and new, extending about 6 inches onto the wall cavity you! Worth more with plaster walls for any distress this caused you and best of luck with your.... Rewired and fish through the internet but am coming up short just going. ; rehab it with a piece of drywall and it ’ s here. Softer drywall requires some practice anyway ) just wanted to thank you for helping me more. Abhor drywall and plaster wall construction used before sheetrock flippers here are crass and ignorant and all. Stucco finishes have many of you know if they used an accelerator or retarder in. Caused you and best of luck with your work you plan to do stucco vs drywall yourself much! Can match any texture, but they ’ re made for DIYers attorney for a far more wall... In some obsessive Compulsive personality traits stucco vs drywall everything home improvement on the interior walls are original! Many of you know if they are inspecting during these sequences but some departments longer! Comparing Kleenex and generic facial tissues finish effects can also be good sources for recommended installers plaster! Repairable space more decorative in texture and color since it is difficult to sand, and the figures themselves debated... But some departments no longer do this purchase and install something wider referred.
Soup Pack Pick N Pay, Clover Configurator For Catalina, Where To Buy Fritz-kola Uk, Plow For Front Of Lawn Mower, Great Pyrenees Duke, Apple Cider Fireball Jello Shots, Best Organic Shampoo For Thinning Hair, Gucci Sunglasses With Bee On Frame, Nikon Rumors Z9, Open Up Your Eyes I'll Show You Love Something Beautiful,